Skip to main content

Immigration debate should be fact-based

A recent University of South Carolina study concluded that the effects of the Latino presence in the state are mixed, with wage depression occurring only in some sectors. It also concluded that the still small (but growing) Latino presence in South Carolina has led tosmall education and health care costs. This study also noted that despite an increasing Latino presence in health care facilities, Latinos do not appear to be overwhelming the system. For example, in 2005 Latinos made up only 1.6 percent of all hospital discharges (inpatient, outpatient or emergency room visits).

The study also pointed out that federal funding has provided some of the resources needed by the South Carolina public education system to provide services to Latinos. Furthermore, schools are also community centers that bring together cultural and linguistic diversity that will be needed by students who will compete in an increasingly globalized world.

A recent Urban Institute study concluded that Mexicans (the major Latino immigrant group in South Carolina) were the only group for which unlawful entry was the dominant offense. Moreover, businesses that hire undocumented workers take out of their pay worker's compensation and Social Security deductions, as well as insurance and federal income tax.

Until we have comprehensive federal immigration reform, I hope that the discussion of the impact of undocumented workers can be done without "scapegoating" Latinos or any other group.
Fred Gebler

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Some Inspiration

If you want to make changes in the world, you're going to have to be there day after day doing the boring, straightforward work of getting people interested in an issue, building a slightly bigger organization, carrying out the next move, experiencing frustration, and finally getting somewhere, that's how the world changes -  Noam Chomsky I stayed up last night reading  Imperial Ambitions  by Noam Chomsky and I came across that line, and even though he was talking about the anti-war movement , I think this appeals to the immigration movement, the Dream Act movement or any kind of movement that wants to succeed.

Ignorance Wars

Gheen Vs Gilchrist (this is so funny) It only took Simcox two days to pile on and take his cheap shot at Jim Gilchrist as well. He and his friend William Gheen (ALIPAC) have started a “destroy Gilchrist and Huckabee” campaign with help from among the kooks and zealots of the movement. William Gheen, President of ALIPAC, has had a personal grudge against Jim Gilchrist since the Minuteman Project was founded. Gheen makes his living soliciting donations from unsuspecting Americans in the name of border security. What most people don’t know is just how much of the donor money coming into his organization Gheen pockets. He has never opened his books to the public or explained what happened to the money that many hard working people have given to him. William Gheen uses fear- mongering and race baiting to scare old people out of their savings with stories of “the savage invasion from the Southern border”. When Gilchrist founded the Minuteman Project many patriots believed that Jim was doing ...